Wrong, wrong, wrong (again)

My word, but I called that referendum wrong. My prediction was a long way off the mark. On the other hand, I still stand by my claim that this has been a successful exercise in democracy.

What made the difference? Probably, the emergence into the democratic process of the hopeless, of those who felt alienated from politics and who had – in many instances – felt that way for many years. They didn’t have their voices heard, partly because they were deemed ‘inappropriate’ in modern Britain, partly because they gave up speaking out.

There wasn’t a massive turnout, as some had predicted – it was merely back to the kind of level we used to see in general elections in the late twentieth century. It was the return to the polls of those who’d been excluded since New Labour appeared to turn its back on the working class. And, frankly, I didn’t expect them to turn out this time. Happily, they did.

Unhappily, they didn’t vote in the same way as me. Which is perhaps not surprising: I live in North London, where the vote was three-to-one in favour of Remain.

But even if my prediction was entirely useless, I would, in my defence, point out that I’d have done better if I listened to myself occasionally. For years I’ve been arguing that there was a massive shift in politics coming, that the gulf between the cultural and the political moods of the country was too great to be sustainable.

And last year, in a piece that was again completely wrong on the outcome of the Labour Party leadership election, I suggested that this referendum might be the crunch moment. ‘At some point in the next two years,’ I wrote, ‘the political class is going to have to put itself up for approval by the population of the country. The ostensible issue is our membership of the European Union, but it’ll be surprising if that’s the sole item on the agenda.’ That, at least, was a good call. But clearly I wasn’t paying attention.

2 thoughts on “Wrong, wrong, wrong (again)

  1. Mmm. You talk about the political class having to line up to be approved by the electorate. Well, that may be. But let’s take a look at what’s happened. In my office, which Is predominately populated by twenty and thirty somethings, the talk, after the initial shock was cultural positioning. What it means to be British, European, French. It wasn’t about the politics of the event. What’s happened is the Tory right-wing, aided by powerful media allies, is staging something of a coup. Push enough cultural buttons, mix it up, and get your political project through any door that opens. In this election, it was immigration. But l do agree with you on one point, Alwynne: this election result is wrong, wrong, wrong.


  2. Julian,
    I disagree. The Brexiteers were not just the Tory Right wing, but many Labour voters. For example, the North East voted for Brexit and it surely isn’t Tory.
    The Remnants were mainly Blairite, of either party….or in fact just the one party really no matter what the party label.
    And no, the result wasn’t wrong….it was a democratic result.
    The Blairites are now after Corbyn, seeking to overturn his perfectly valid election by Labour members.
    So the referendum was democracy in action, and the coup against Corbyn is the Blairite elite seeking to overturn a democratic decision. I hope Corbyn wins, he is the most honest man in politics…..and I’m not a Labour supporter, but I surely will be if he wins.


Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.